It has been six long seasons since the Newtown Sandy Hooks have had any success challenging the mighty Brooklyn Atlantics. One needs only to search the record books to 2006 to uncover that single glorious day when the likes of 'Pops' and 'Express' Pendergist, 'Rock' Zulli, 'Moose' Margolis, the Dieckman twins shocked the base ball world with a resounding 12 to 10 win over the Atlantics on their home turf on Long Island.

Turn-Back-The-Clock: Newtown verses Atlantics - 2006

Since that time the Atlantics have frustrated every attempt the Sandy Hooks have made to best the Brooklyn nine.

On Saturday the Newtown Sandy Hooks traveled to the Smithtown Historical Society grounds at the far reaches of Long Island too try their luck at taming the potent adversary on his home grounds.

A formidable nine of Wheat, Toomey, Maleri, Smith, Ortiz, Friedman, Scarinzi, Donnelly and Chris Ortiz, recruited from the ranks of Bucknell club ball, met at the fearsome yet picturesque grounds the Atlantics call home for a1864 and 1886 set.

Since none of the Sandy Hooks '60's era pitchers were able to make the trip, 'Lightning' Toomey accepted the responsibility for what was expected to be the 'quick' warm-up for the 'ultimate match' at 12:30. Little did anyone know what a drawn-out affair they were about to observe and what the cagy Atlantics had in store for their guests.

Ed 'Pigtail' Elmore called the two teams to order and outlined the complicated ground rules for the Smithfield grounds. Toomey won the bat toss for the visitors and chose 'home side' and second at-bats and from that point to two hours hence, it all went seriously wrong for the Sandy Hooks.

In the first inning, using a freshly wound ball, the tempestuous Atlantics blasted pitch after Toomey pitch to the far reaches of the yard to score a seemly insurmountable eight aces in the twenty minute plus inning. 'Dream' Emma and 'Flash' Harrison lashed monumental discharges that bounded over fences, caromed into trees and skirted into neighboring yards to highlight the notable outburst. In return the Atlantic's veteran 'Willy Mo' Stelmach rolled through inning after inning limiting the Sandy Hooks to singles and occasional runs while Toomey and the Hooks tried to find their sea legs. As usual, the Newtown batters managed to get good wood on the ball, but their towering blasts typically ended up being caught on a bound or in spectacular fashion by the Atlantic's mister reliable 'TC' Cannino.

Toomey, Maleri and 'Papi' Ortiz were able to muster some firepower for the Sandy Hooks but to little avail as the visitors never got closer than six runs (in the second inning) to the Atlantic juggernaut. The long-winded nine inning affair took well over two hours to perform and in the end, the Atlantic ran away with a 20 to 8, never in doubt, victory.

After some lengthy negotiations regarding the lack of a backstop (due to a sheep pen that had been erected on the site) the two sides decided to attempt to play an 1886 game in the old ball yard.

A brief memorial service was held by Ed Elmore as the Atlantics honored the later day Brooklyn Atlantic and vintage base ball founder 'Old Dutch' Dieckmann.

In game two the Sandy Hooks chose to bat second and the battery of Toomey and 'Bison' Friedman readied to do battle for the second weekend in a row. In the previous week, Friedman hurled the Newtowners to a brilliant 3-2 victory over the Providence Grays in Colt Meadows. The hope was that maybe he could quiet Brooklyn bats long enough for the Sandy Hook bats to reawaken and find their full potential.

The Sandy Hooks immediately found 'Wild Horse' Ferchland's pitching enticing as Friedman and Maleri combined to scrape together a single run in the first, then Smith and Scarinzi in the second inning. At the same time, Friedman sent a mesmerizing array of pitches across the dish in the first three innings that accounted for just a single run for Brooklyn and three satisfying strikeouts for the Hook hurler.

For four innings both hurlers seemed to have the situation well in order with the Sandy Hooks and Atlantics knotted in a two two tie.

In the top of the fifth frame, in an effort help his own cause, 'Bison' Friedman laced a single to right center to ignite a four run rally. Hit after satisfying hit scored successive runs to increase the visitor's margin to 6-2. The Atlantics countered with runs in the fifth and sixth to close the margin to 6-5. In the seventh, 'Dirt' Smith ignited a three run outburst as Friedman continued to toil and hold on to his more comfortable but still tenuous lead. In the eighth, Toomey reignited the Sandy Hook offence with a booming double followed by four singles, another double by Scarinzi, and a Friedman triple to beyond the distant rightfield shrubbery cleared six aces for his side. With a little three run icing initiated by 'Crash' Wheat in the ninth a victory felt certainly in hand.

'Bison', still having enough in the tank to complete his sterling effort, struct-out two Atlantic batters in the last of the ninth to bring home a glorious and well-deserved 18-8 victory that will go down in the history books.

Stars for the Sandy Hooks in game two included everyone on the roster.

'Bison' Friedman was the unanimous 'star of the day' throwing a ten hitter, striking out seven batters and knotting his second complete game win in two tries. At the bat he was five for six with a triple and three runs batted in.

'Barkeep' Donnelly had a disappointing day at the plate only mustering one hit all day. On the defense, he made fabulous plays in the field including sparkling catches (that equaled Cannino) and showed great skill in handling the horrendous assortment of trees, bushes, brambles, fences and farm implements in deep center.

'Lightning' Maleri ignited many fires with his bat as he was 7 for 11 for the day. Along with wearing out Brooklyn fielders with his gap-opening hits, he played flawlessly at short all day.

'Thunder' puts a scare into any team. In spite of his less than sparkling debut on the line in game one, Tristan Toomey continued to amaze in his backstopping efforts in the 1886 match as he played stunning defense. In the hitting column, he entertained the cranks with a copious number of sky rockets (some that ended-up being caught on the bound in game one) that resulted in an 8 for 11 at the plate.

'Crash' Wheat did a diligent job captaining the Newtown nine and had the good judgment to choose the 80's game as the Hooks encore event. He was 3 for 6 in game two with two RBI's

'Papi' Ortiz continued to show his prowess as a dependable run producer in spite of a nagging ankle injury that sidelined him earlier. He was 7 for 11 for the day and 3 for 6 in the winning effort.

'Dirt' Smith's bat was quiet in game one but came alive in game to go 3 for 6 and drive in three Sandy Hook runs.

'Lefty' Scarinzi left nothing on the field in game two as he was 5 for 6 with two doubles and 4 runs-batted-in.

The Hooks 'muffin' second sacker 'Kowla' Ortiz proved to be no muffin at all as he hit 4 for 10 in his initial matches and took numerous throws from the backstop and made critical putouts when called upon.

Next Saturday Atlantics return to McLaughlin Vineyards for Lobster Fest weekend to try to set the record straight. Even though, the Sandy Hooks showed they have all the talent to win at 1880's ball, the diminutive size of the McLaughlin Vineyard ball yard forces the club to depend solely on 1860's ballwhich is always the Atlantic's strong suit.

June 4 - Smithtown Historical Society

Brooklyn Atlantics 20 - Newtown Sandy Hooks 8 (1864)
Tristan 'Thunder' Toomey LP
Anthony 'Willy Mo' Stelmach WP

Newtown Sandy Hook 18 - Brooklyn Atlantics 8 (1886)
Pete 'Bison' Friedman Newtown Sandy Hook WP
George 'Wild Horse' Ferchland LP

Toomey drives a 'Wild Horse' pitch around the ever present willow in dead center as 'Pigtail' Elmore adjudicates.

 

'Dirt' Smith tries to avoid tag at third

Atlantic manages to avoid 'Dirt' Smith at third while 'Barkeep' Donnelly backs-up play

Newtown's 'Saltan of Sweat'

 

A rare sight at Smithtown grounds. 'Papi' Ortiz and 'Lefty' Scarinzi guard against a ninth inning rally.

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
 

Check Back for more Game Pix
 
   


 

 
 
 

© Newtown Sandy Hook Vintage Base Ball Club, Newtown, CT